Skip to content

The Annual General Meeting is about reporting to members on the previous year, April 2019-March 2020. In the last few weeks of March, we went into lockdown and we are now cautiously restarting our working parties and developing responses to the climate and ecological crises.  The pandemic took attention away from the crises, although it is deeply interlinked with them.  The decrease in emissions in the first phase of global lockdown didn’t last long and – like the virus - the crises have not gone away.  Unlike the virus, there is not an active international programme to find a way to reduce their threat.  The most urgent action we all need to take is to lockdown our own fossil fuel use, and to convince family, friends and work-places to do the same.

MCF’s aims as a charity are to create and manage woodlands and related environmental assets, to pass on the skills involved, and to increase public appreciation of and involvement with trees, hedgerows and woodlands.  We will be concentrating on planting and managing trees to capture and lock up carbon; to help stabilise and increase the health of soils; to maintain and increase biodiversity; and to contribute to natural recovery networks, enabling adaptation to change.  

We are establishing our own tree nursery, to sow tree seed, and bring on seedlings and saplings for our own use in planting programmes.  We hope to have mini-nurseries spread across different localities, each perhaps concentrating on one or two types of tree: if you have some space to give over to some nursery beds, please let us know through the website.  We will provide guidance, and have applied for grants to provide equipment to propagate and protect the plants.

Next summer and autumn, we will be asking people to collect seeds and saplings for us, within a legal and ethical framework to prevent damage to local ecologies and to remain good citizens and neighbours.  We will have guidance for good practice in place early next year and hope to have tools and equipment to lend and co-ordinators to help early summer, 2021.  However, if you have tree seeds and seedlings of native trees in your own garden that would otherwise end up on the compost heap or the bonfire, please think of collecting them for us first and contact us through the website.

We are actively looking for places to plant trees and hedgerows.  In the past we have concentrated on looking for existing woodlands to buy, or large areas to convert to woodland.  Local patterns of land-ownership and the loss of value of land converted to woodland have blocked that path so far. Our current projects depend on relatively small areas of land and management partnerships with owners.  Instead of seeing these as ‘meanwhile’ developments, we now intend to develop multiple smaller sites across the Malvern district, through partnerships or purchase.  We will look at sites from a few square metres up to tennis court-size for intensive planting of native trees and woodland plants.    We also want to work on restoring, enhancing and doubling up existing hedgerows to produce ‘linear woodlands’ of huge biodiversity value. Let us know via our website if you think you have spotted somewhere with potential, and we will check it out.

Our existing projects are all founded on similar principles, though may get a re-tuning to maximise their contribution to adapting to and mitigating the crises. We will be able to do more with more volunteers and members, and are working to increase their both their number and diversity. Come and join in!

Full details of the AGM are here

Project News

Abundance:

Is in its dormant phase, though there is still some apple juice available to buy.

Cuillin’s Wood:

The Twixtmas event on 28th December event was another satisfying session for seeing 3-13 year olds experience the wonder and joy of woodland activities and crafts.   It was also warmed by mulled apple juice and toasted marshmallows.  An advance release for the Malvern Gazette was published in the Worcester News instead and a Worcester family sought us out. We realised how we have missed opportunities for attracting families passing by en route to the Hills: we put up signs to get to the Wood, but not on what’s happening there!

We were approached some time ago about offering sessions in the wood for families unused to outdoor activities, funded by the WCC Family Learning Service. We have not been able to find the time/the tutors to set them up. We are hoping to find a person with Forest School or similar training to take the lead.

The next event will be the Friday of Half-Term, February 22nd, 11:00-2:00

Malvern Link Station:

We have been regularly digging through challenging rubble, to be able to plant various types of hedges along the Birmingham platform. It has been just as challenging working out how to get soil on site, working through two
risk-sensitive bureaucracies.  We have been informed it took two years to negotiate soil onto the beds along the Hereford platform.  We’re still hopeful that we’ll get some planting done before the end of March.  As for the signage: texts sent off and need to be found in the system.  Spring has come to the woodland area, and the apple trees are in bud.  We will be planting more native daffodils, some bluebells and wood-anemones, and more pond plants.  Did anyone see the magnificent show of star fungi?

Prospect Community Woodland:

Working parties have been concentrating on clearing the small rubble mound, and getting stones off-site.  The door to the compost toilet has been repaired and strengthened.  We are hoping to thin some of the trees soon and use the timber to build benches for use initially at Cuillin’s Wood.  We now have a range of carving tools, and are in the process of purchasing equipment for hedge-laying: basic kit for training and out-door activities at Prospect and other sites. 

Townsend Community Woodland:

After a very busy season last year in bringing part of the woodland back into management as coppice, this year Townsend has had relatively little input.  That’s about to change.  We have started to work on osier regeneration, for future willow weaving; are cutting logs to hire out to a wedding; and are preparing two jigs for making hurdles (initially to go on Malvern Link station).  The joint Management Plan with Malvern Hills Trust (MHT) ends this year, and a new one is to be developed.  Part of the plan involves our mowing team providing a mowing programme for the Memorial Orchard, over the spring/summer.  MHT – that is, Beck – has got funding for some developments in the woodland to increase access, which she briefed a group of us on recently.  There will be formal announcements over the next few weeks.

Development Updates

Tree, Hedgerow and Woodland Policy:

We have made a number of submissions to local development plans, building on the research and work Ken and Jules are doing about developing the policy. The basic arguments and parameters for this strategy are in the submissions. The texts for these are on our web-site. We have set a deadline for presenting this strategy, and will be working hard over the late spring/summer to assemble stakeholders, come to a consensus, and providing an initial draft.

Madresfield Estate:

Our hedge-laying training day was fully subscribed, and very productive. The hedge might not win any prizes, but was a great start and an inspiration to developing our skills. The Estate Manager was impressed enough to ask how the Estate could support us further. We are going to set up a rolling programme around part of the estate to bring hedges back into management, and are discussing restoring one of the estate’s coppices to producing stakes and binders (heatherings) for hedge-laying. There’s also the possibility of collaborating in their orchards. The Estate is also happy for us to publicise our collaboration.

Members, volunteers and friends of Malvern Community Forest,

On one of the news programme’s end-of-year review, a professor from a Sheffield University was asked whether he thought the drastic levels of change in behaviour, economics, and attitudes necessary to minimise the amount of climate change were likely to happen.  His reply was, to paraphrase: enormous changes are inevitable over the next 30 years; either we voluntarily change in radical ways or we will have drastic changes forced upon us from massive increases in global temperature and its disastrous consequences.  Let’s change voluntarily!

If the disastrous consequences were only for humans, there might be some poetic justice in doing nothing, but we will be accompanied in our peril by thousands of other species, by people who have made little or no contribution to the situation, and those to come.   Researchers suggest we have a shrinking window of opportunity for radical measures to reduce global temperature change, up to 2030.  Trees and woodlands - and more recently, hedgerows – have long been linked with directly locking up carbon, as well as mitigating other impacts of climate change.  How should MCF respond to the escalating crisis of climate change, wild-life extinction, and habitat loss?

In the last two years or so, MCF has been slowly expanding its activities locally, to increase people’s awareness of and involvement with woodland and associated wild-life habitats. The crisis calls for more concentrated, combined action.  We are extending our range of partner organisations and are in discussions with major local land-owners about joint projects to increase tree cover.  We have recently involved ourselves in planning policy, contributing to consultations on the AONB Management Plan, the South Worcestershire Development Plan Review, and the Malvern Neighbourhood Plan. This is part of a strategy for retaining, adding to and sustaining trees, woodlands and hedgerows, described in the next section.  Our next step is to ask members, volunteers and friends to respond positively to the crisis, as explained in the final section.

Strategy for sustaining trees, woodlands and hedgerows

Trees, hedgerows and woodlands are typical of all of South Worcestershire but despite their recognised social, environmental, health and indirect economic benefits, these environmental assets are in long-term decline.  Land-management, agricultural practices and global economics that led to their decline are now being questioned, partly because of their contribution to environmental degradation and to climate change.   Retaining and improving woodlands and hedgerows, and retaining and increasing tree cover depends on them having a valued economic role as well as being a natural good. 

However, saw mills and other necessary infrastructure has been closing down, and is now below a critical mass for a locally sustainable woodland economy. We are therefore encouraging initiatives to re-launch local woodland economies. Innovative approaches such as Woodland Hubs are needed, focussing collaboration across the private, not-for-profit and agency sectors to develop opportunities for wood-based work and crafts, locally-sourced building timber, and high quality woodland products.

An accessible and attractive market-place and knowledgeable and appreciative purchasers are part of a thriving local woodland economy. Whilst woodland, hedgerows and their products will mostly be based in rural settings, consumers are mostly in urban settings.  Retaining and managing trees and hedgerows in the urban environment and at the street level builds knowledge and appreciation as well as being important for bio-diversity and providing easy access to some of the social, environmental and health benefits of woodland. In this more stressful environment for trees, their long-term health depends on retaining their soil and their immediate surroundings, which carries their fungal support systems: replacement planting is very much second best.

Re-establishing the local woodland economy and using this eco-system approach to retain, enhance and sustain existing trees, hedgerows and woodland needs a specific supplementary planning document. This will provide guidance to public bodies, developers, planners and people living and working in South Worcestershire in decision- making about these vital environment assets.  We are bringing stakeholders together to develop such a document and turn it into policy.

How members, volunteers and friends can respond positively

Whilst protest has a place, MCF’s strength is in getting on with creating and caring for woodlands and trees, and using their products.  To rise to the challenge, we need more members and volunteers working with us on projects, and in running MCF.  Members and friends who can’t be so directly involved can still have an active role.  Shouting about what we are doing and why with people in your networks and neighbourhood - digitally and face-to-face - will help us build momentum and gain support. Look out for and tell us about opportunities for planting trees or hedgerows and for restoring neglected hedgerows or woodland. We fund our projects by getting grants and donations from outside bodies. However, we also need to start a Sustainability Fund for our general running costs – insurance, licences, consumables – which grants usually don’t cover. Donations can be made specifically for this fund.  Last but not least, join in by giving us feedback and sharing your ideas.  

4

Introduction

In 2016 the Trustees reviewed Malvern Community Forest’s (MCF’s) strategy, to build on its successes, identify opportunities and challenges and develop responses to them. At the end of the year they proposed changes to MCF’s stated aims and purposes in its Constitution to cover all aspects of what we are doing.  These were accepted at the AGM in March 2017.

The Trustees wanted to involve members and friends in developing a new strategy through this interactive blog.  We want to have an exchange of ideas, rather than voting on a list of proposals we’ve made. The section on Background describes some of the issues as the Trustees see them: are there others we need to address? We have identified some areas of principle, and some options that we would welcome comment on.  We welcome any other principals or other options or proposals.  What else do you think could contribute to MCF’s development?

These conversations were open until November 30th 2017.

A draft strategy will be prepared from these contributions and conversations and posted on this site at the end of January 2018 for comment.  The draft will be finalised at the Trustees’ meeting in April 2018, and circulated for voting on at the AGM in June 2018.

Background

In May 2016 the Trustees reviewed MCF’s strategy of raising funds and acquiring woodlands and other habitats to meet its aim of restoring the character of Malvern Chase. The historic Malvern Chase consisted of 13 parishes, from Powick to Chase End, including two to the west of the Hills.

MCF’s successful projects at the time were Townsend and Prospect Community Woods and Abundance Malvern.  These projects are in or close to the Malvern area, and involve relatively small areas of woodland and orchard.  The Chair and Trustees had been successful in gaining sponsorship and grants from a number of enterprises and public agencies. Work on the projects depended on a core group of 10-15 members all living in the Malvern area, with different amounts and type of support from 30-40 other members.

Expanding current projects or taking on further projects, large or small, would be challenging.  Going outside the immediate Malvern area would require recruiting support local to the project.  Grants and sponsorships are typically given for developing projects or aspects of projects, and it is much more difficult to get funding for continuing maintenance over longer time-spans. As awareness of MCF’s work had grown, significant legacies and other one-off donations had provided some of the needed flexibility for a limited period.

As a first step, we need to increase active membership.  Working on projects. recruiting members and volunteers, finding innovative funding, and widening our activities,  take time and effort.

Towards the end of 2016, the Trustees agreed to update our aims and purposes as written in our Constitution to cover what we were doing in our projects and how we were spending moneys from members and granting bodies.  New Objects for the Charity were circulated to members and were approved at our AGM in March 2017.  The changes were intended to clarify that any woodland or other habitats would be used as well as established and maintained, and that MCF can work in partnerships to meet its aims. (Link to new Objects)

Principles

To provide educational, health and environmental benefits for the local and wider community through our activities

Community access – any projects MCF is involved in must provide access to the site by members of the public

Community involvement – where possible, each individual project will have its own group from the local area to advise and support the project

Build partnerships – MCF will actively build partnerships with individuals, communities, charities and other agencies to meet its aims

Using woodland and other habitats.  Allowing woodlands to revert to zero management over the 300 years it takes is likely to lead to them being grubbed out long before then as ‘wasted land’, ‘unsightly’, or ‘not safe’.   Unless they are close to other long-established woodlands, they may not regenerate anyway through lack of genetic and ecological exchange.

Woodlands have only existed in the UK because they provided fuel and the materials for many other products; wild flower meadows existed because of the way they were previously used for fodder. The greatest health benefits come from being active in these habitats.

What other principles do you think MCF should follow?

Organisational Options

The ‘Growth’ model vs the ‘Organic’ model

The Organic model is the way MCF has grown until now.  We have been approached by other bodies - the Conservators (as they were), the Civic Society - who wanted our help in managing woodland or pieces of land.  Abundance joined forces with MCF to build synergies. In creating Prospect Community Woodland, MCF Trustees identified a piece of land that could be restored and approached the owners; in another, an opportunity was seized through funding available in another project to promote public involvement with Malvern’s Marvellous Trees.

Members and funds have waxed and waned, but steady progress has been maintained.  Our current position of doing as much as we can with the resources we have may be an ultimate limit, or might just be a pause before the next step forward. We spend what we have on our projects, keeping only a small reserve.  The age profile of active members and membership more generally may be a limit in the fullness of time.

The Growth model is based on economic growth and the way organisations – private, public or charities - have to have a steady rate of growth in order to survive.  The successful organisation accumulates capital: financial – substantial reserve funds; human – highly skilled and specialised personnel; intellectual – having protected special knowledge others will pay for; and reputational capital – an established place in the market, based on reliable delivery of quality goods or products.  On this model, MCF is still a start-up: yet to build funds; having a few skilled personnel and mostly dependent on untrained people; intellectual capital consisting of knowledge and skills that have largely fallen out of wider use, or had limited application.  We have mostly reputational capital, with loyal members, a rising local profile, and individuals and organisations that approach us for help.

Public perception of our competitors for funds and personnel might be the Malvern Hills Trust, the Wildlife Trust, and the Woodland Trust.  We are partners with the Malvern Hills Trust in managing Townsend Community Woodland, but neither they nor the other organisations have been directly involved in our other projects.

Following the Growth model would require us to recruit members with specialisms in fund raising, recruiting volunteers and members, and public relations/communication, to work alongside the people who like getting their hands dirty with trees, land and wild-life. This would enable us to attract more funding and provide more systematic training to build skills and knowledge.

What other models do you think we could follow?  What would be your preferences?

What should Malvern Community Forest be doing?

Our current Projects match the activities listed in our Objects in the following ways

Abundance uses particular environmental assets for the health benefits of the local and wider community, whilst promoting the environmental benefits of reducing food waste.  We work in partnership with charities in doing so.  It also promotes associated crafts and skills (making fruit juice; cider making).

Malvern Link Station is establishing and maintaining woodland and other habitats for the environmental and educational benefits of the local and wider community, as well as promotion of MCF and its partners to a wider public.  We work in partnership with charities and other agencies, to increase awareness, knowledge and appreciation of environmental assets.

Malvern’s Marvellous Trees is a project of educational and health benefits, working with charities and other agencies to increase the awareness, knowledge, appreciation and involvement of the general public with established trees in the town and its surroundings.

Prospect Community Woodland is establishing and maintaining woodland and other environmental assets for the health and environmental benefit of the local and wider community.  We work in partnership with the local community and other agencies to increase awareness, knowledge and appreciation of its environmental assets.  The site has been used to host social events and annual training sessions in associated crafts and skills for the general public.

Townsend Community Woodland is developing and maintaining woodland and other environmental assets for the health and environmental benefit of the local and wider community.  We work in partnership with the Malvern Hills Trust to increase awareness, knowledge and appreciation of its environmental assets, and in our new projects providing opportunities to increase involvement in associated crafts and skills.

What changes in priorities would you like to see?  Do we need to add other activities?

Finally, anything else you would like to comment on or suggest?